Veritas On-line logo Napier Students' Newspaper banner

truth logo

December 2002

Issue 4

Veritas Sections

Home

University News

News Analysis

Features

Sport

Campaigns

Arts & Entertainment

Editorial

Comments

Veritas Links

Message Board

Polls

Napier Resources

Intranet

Email

WebPAC

Careers

Other Resources

Google

BBC News

Napier Students Association

City of Edinburgh Council

Lothian buses

Edinburghguide.com

Controversy Rages Over Student Representation

by Sarah Stiles

AT A RECENT Academic Board meeting, Napier Students’ Association (NSA) verbally attacked Napier University for cutting back student rights relating to the Academic Appeals Procedure and the Discipline Procedure.

According to the NSA’s in-house Reporter newsletter, the association argued the case for student rights against the university management, but in the end it was decided that students no longer have the right to representation at hearings involving academic appeals and discipline.

The timescale for appealing decisions made by the university has now decreased and now the university can administer fines on students for disciplinary actions.

This led to harsh comments from members of the NSA delegation, mainly Neil Freshwater, the Campaigns and Representation Sabbatical.

Mr. Freshwater said the University refused to listen and that they were “dismissive.” He went on to say that: “Napier’s senior management is not well known for having an open and consultative style of leadership.”

Dr. Gerry Webber, University Secretary and Registrar said: “All decisions of the University Court and its subsidiary bodies, including the Academic Board, are regarded as collective decisions; therefore, I cannot comment for individual members of the Board on this situation.”

He did say that new procedures regarding academic appeals and student discipline were approved at the last meeting, where students were represented. He also mentioned that the University Court would approve new procedures for student complaints in December.

“Students will again be directly represented here as they were in the last meeting,” said Dr. Webber.

At the last student senate, held on 2nd December, Angela Mitchell stressed that they “had a strong campaign, with strong arguments”, and that despite NSA winning the debate, the university management had succeeded in pushing through measures that Mitchell claimed would cut back on basic student rights.

Mitchell added that she was considering some form of ‘name and shame’ campaign as the first step in trying to reverse the decision.